Best Protein Powder Review-Many Choices, Best Selection

Best Protein Powder Review-Many Choices, Best Selection

There are definitely good reasons to have a protein powder supplement in your diet. Because there is a use, even a need, there are a TON of protein powder options out there. I investigated in depth, to help sort out and give you the best protein powder review.

best protein powders for a Buff BodyUses for Protein Powder

There are three main reasons to add a protein powder to your diet. One is to add needed protein after a hard workout, to build lean muscle mass. For that you want a fast absorption protein drink.

For those looking to lose weight and belly fat, a protein powder drink can be a way to add protein and other nutrients to your diet while keeping the calorie count down. In this case, you will want a meal replacement protein powder that is filling and absorbs slowly, so you keep a more full feeling.

The third use is to maintain your weight and health as you age. People who are older require more nutrients, including protein, but the metabolism is slower, so a good protein powder is a good way to keep a proper nutritional balance. For this group, a slower acting protein source works best.


Recommended Whey Protein Powders

For these rankings, I used this scale:

0-5 Protein quality

Proteins may get higher rankings for any of the following: independently verified, have Branched chain amino acids, have full range of amino acids, have good protein combinations for both quick and lasting action

0-5 Taste

Based on a broad range of reviews, to reflect many opinions, not just mine

0-5 Additives and Sweeteners

If there are additives they contribute to nutrition to get a higher ranking. I gave anything with sucralose or fructose or aspartame a low ranking, while low-glycemic natural stevia got higher rankings. Organic flavors gets high rankings too.

Price per Serving

I used 20 grams of protein as the serving size in determining the price per serving, even though each product has its own recommended serving size.

This means that the highest possible ranking is a 15, while zero is the lowest. In picking my top picks, I considered the cost factor. The least costly options have not proven to be the best, nor have the most expensive ones. The ones I like best cost $1.23 to $1.29 a serving.


Tera's Whey SImply PureTera's Whey is my number one rated whey protein. It is produced from local farmers in Wisconsin. The company has the product periodically tested for content and purity by independent 3rd party labs. The whey protein is very good quality Concentrated Whey. They also make both an organic and an isolate whey powder, but with the independent testing, I do not recommend paying extra for that. It is non GMO, and has all natural ingredients. The sweetener used is stevia.  It gets about a perfect ranking for a pure best protein powder review.



I give this one a ranking of 15. What tips it into first place for me is the independent testing and obtaining product from small Wisconsin farms.

The cost is $1.29 per 20 gEach serving is 110 calories. 

2 scoops=20 g protein


The Next Two are Also Very Close

My next two favorites are very close. They cost almost the same as Tera's Whey and both get a 15 on the ranking.

How do you choose? I believe your choice will depend on whether the product is in stock more than anything. If you try all of them, you will probably find one that is your favorite for texture, or packaging, or taste. It can be individual. What I can tell you is all three of these are delicious, are sweetened with stevia, not artificial sweeteners, and have high quality ingredients. The calorie counts differ and that may have an impact on you.

Also, the scoop sizes are different. I standardized the grams of protein at 20 for the rankings, but how many grams you want in a serving may help you decide which of these three products is best for you.Whey Factors

Whey Factors is a combination of concentrate and isolate, and that qualifies for both post-workout and for meal replacement. It also contains added BCAA's. It has no artificial ingredients, tastes good, and is non-GMO with good fats.

Protein Taste Additives Price Calories/20grams protein Scoop size

The cost is $1.27 per 20 grams, with 100 calories. 

1 scoop = 16g protein

Jay Robb Isolate Whey
The other one I like a lot is Jay Robb Whey Protein. It is 100% Isolate, so especially good for workouts. It is immensely popular, and there is good reason for that. It has good flavor, is non GMO and non-gluten, with natural ingredients.

Protein Taste Additives Price Calories/20grams protein Scoop size

The cost of a 100 calorie, 20 gram protein serving is $1.23.

1 scoop = 25 g protein


Runners Up in this Best Protein Powder Review

The top value pick is Myotein Whey Protein Complex. Myotein Whey Protein ComplexMyotein has created this one with a combination of 6 different whey proteins. It is really a marketing ploy, because they are not needed to be effective. It also uses artificial sweeteners.

But it is less costly than the ones that are the top-rated, and it is a decent value for the money. The cost per 20 grams is only 73 cents, and the calories are 96. A scoop is designed to give you 25 grams of protein.

This one gets a 13.

One runner-up is 18 Shake, which is a combination of whey, but not as many as six. It is sweetened with stevia and contains an appetite suppressant. It better suppress appetite at a cost of $4.72 for 20 grams of protein! It has good quality, although not better than the lower cost options I recommended earlier.  This gets a 12.

Herbalife is another higher cost good quality protein powder that costs a lot at $3.15 per 20 gram serving. In my opinion, there is no reason to buy either one of these.  With a ranking of 12, I recommend you go with one of the first three here.

ding better choices for best protein powders availableDING

I want to mention a few products that sell way more than they should in my opinion.  I think when we talking about a best protein powder review, we need to look at the ones that fail to measure up, too.

Naked Whey sounds really good as being 100% un-denatured grass-fed whey concentrate. The price is about right at $1.20 for grams of protein. But it can have variable quality and taste, so why do it?

BSN Syntha-6 is a combination of multi-whey but also contains Soy. It is not gluten-free.

Isopure Zero Carb Protein Powder comes in 14 flavors and has 50% of the minimum daily requirement of many vitamins and minerals, but contains sucralose.

LaBrada Lean Body have some lower quality additives and contain both fructose and sucralose. It has 290 calories per serving. and/or fructose.

Muscle Milk has added vitamins and minerals, but contains sucralose , magnesium oxide (ineffective and cheap) and acefulmine sulfate.

Slim Fast is a milk protein concentrate, has a thickening agent that has been shown to be a bowel irritant, and has high sugar. You find it everywhere, and with so many sweet and sugar addicts, it gets bought a lot.

GNC Total Lean is similar.  I used to buy this, until I learned about all the better ones that are out there.

Garden of Life, an organic soy-free, dairy-free product with no artificial flavors or sweeteners, tastes gritty and smells bad.

I am not saying these are awful. I am saying there are better choices you can make.

What It's All About

Why do we buy a protein powder? It is for our health! Does it not make sense to buy one that gives you the best ingredients, for the best price, and avoids artificial sweeteners and other additives?

REMEMBER please, do not overdo your protein intake while getting that sleek physique. It is not healthy for you. Parents, watch what your teens and even young adults are consuming as they workout. There is a lot of advertising out there designed to entice them to buy and use more than they need or is good for them.

Make your choice and enjoy responsibly.






Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Please follow and like us:

Published by Annie Collyer

Annie is a mom of four, a business owner and blogger. She and her husband live in New Hampshire, where they are both active volunteers in their community school district. She writes about designing our lives with proven design thinking principles. Join her in creating the life we each want.

  • eric says:

    Your article on the best protein powder review has some good information, but I would like to know more about plant based proteins if you have any information on that.

    I see that the soy protein is not good, but would like to know more about it, or if there are some good plant based alternatives to it.

  • Steve & Kris says:

    Where did you get that picture of me? Haha, just kidding, maybe more protein powder will do the trick. Sorry, I digress. I have a hard time knowing how much protein I need during the day. I have a shake in the morning, a protein bar after lunch. I have apples and peanut butter for a morning snack and I usually have chicken or some other meat for lunch. Dinner is a wildcard. I am glad to know 40-50% of my body weight is a good rule of thumb. I will keep that tucked away for a reference point. Too much protein is bad for you? I didn’t realize that. It sounds like a balancing act. Thank you for sharing this very informative post, I appreciate it.

  • Prabakaran says:

    We are almost vegetarians and we take meat once in a week. Also since we stay away from family, we cook whatever vegetable we get. Therefore, after reading your useful article, I feel definitely we need to take protein powder and thank you for that. One Question to you. Which protein powder would you recommend for people like me?

    • Hi,  I am glad the almost vegetarian lifestyle works well for you.  As for what protein powder I would recommend, I think that will depend on why you think you need one and whether you are avoiding whey.  It is probable that you are getting enough protein for a normally active lifestyle, just from your diet.  However, if you work out, you may need more.  Is that the case?  If you are avoiding dairy, then the Thrive Protein powder I recommend in this blog will work.  If not, please see the blog on this site reviewing the best protein powders to see what I recommend and why.  That should help you!  Let me know what you decide! Thanks for visiting.

  • […] There are questions today about how much protein is needed to build muscle, and how much is too much perhaps.  Also questions about what sources are good, especially with the many protein powders available today.  Out of the aisles and aisles of protein powders that are made today, which one is best for you?  This post is going to tell you about what is in them.  If you want to cut to the chase, and see what ones we recommend and why, go here. […]

  • […] replace and maintain muscle mass and energy, older folks need more protein and certain minerals and vitamins.  On the link I put here, we have a review of top protein […]

  • […] Another is to consider a protein drink.  Many are loaded with not only protein but other nutrients that can help.  Check out this review. […]

  • minecraft says:

    Outstanding story there. What occurred after? Take care!

  • What do you want to do with your life?

    What do you really want to do for your living? Life Design is within your reach! Sign up here to get the Free EBook Designing Your Life.

    Email Marketing by

    Work is an important part of how we live and what we do, isn't it. So are

    How can we learn to balance our lives, and get everything we want?

    Learn Design Principles so that you can Design the Life  - and the Work - you want to Live. Ask yourself:

    OK, it IS possible.  Now do you want to do that? What would it look like?

    Do you want to design the ideal way for you to be making a living? Get your FREE EBook Designing Your Life- and your FREE ECourse on implementing Life Design in your work life. You can create a life and a job that gets you what you want in life.  This EBook and ECourse will give you the tools

    Don't waste any more time getting what you want in life.  Put your name and email in the form below, and get started on designing the life you want today.

    Email Marketing by

    Invalid email

    You have successfully subscribed to the newsletter

    How and what you think attracts both good and bad into your life:

    The Law of Attraction

    Email Marketing by

    Your thoughts have Power

    You can control how your life goes. Read our FREE ebook on the Law of Attraction and get your free ECourse on how to

    Make the Law work for you - not against you.

    What happens when you don't understand how the Law of Attraction works?

    What do you want? Learn how to manifest what you want in your life. Get your FREE Ebook on the Law of Attraction.  Put your name and email below, and your book will be on its way to you. You'll get your ECourse on how to put the Law of Attraction into effect. You know, don't you, from many past experiences, that you read something once, and then it fades away as life happens. You forget all about it.   You lose it, and you don't get the benefits of what you learned. Frustrating, isn't it? With this ECourse,

    Get started with Attracting What you Want in Life.

    Sign up here.

    Email Marketing by

    Invalid email

    You have successfully subscribed to the newsletter